Beauty

MUAs Agree: 2 Eye Makeup Mistakes That Can Make Your Eyes Looks Smaller

April 24, 2026 by Mariam Qayum
shefinds | Beauty
Featured image

When it comes to makeup, the techniques that once worked in your 20s don’t always translate the same way on mature skin—especially around the eyes. In fact, certain eye makeup habits can unintentionally make eyes appear smaller, darker, and more tired. According to makeup artists, small tweaks—like softening liner or placing concealer more strategically—can instantly brighten and lift the eye area without requiring a full routine overhaul.

house unit img
Say Bye To Wrinkles And Fine Lines — This LED Mask Is The Skin Rejuvenation Game-Changer You Need!

1. Applying Black Shadow To Your Lower Eyelid

One TikTok-trendy hack taking over the internet right now is using black eyeshadow in place of eyeliner for a smudgy, 90s-inspired look. When applied heavily on the lower eyelid, any black shades can create the illusion of smaller eyes, Anastasia Tomchenko, co-founder and CPO of Glambook, warns, and this can also accentuate under-eye bags and wrinkles. To avoid this effect, she says to always think of a softer end goal. "Women over 35 do not need graphic makeup, and the line should be soft," she suggests.

Tomchenko has a great solution to this issue, and explains how to get a gentle cat-eye look that will make your eyes look more refreshed and youthful. "I recommend using a gray or brown color, and a soft formula like kohl can be used to stretch out a line," she adds. Tomchenko notes that "you can blend it while it is fresh or use a slightly dampened angled brush dipped in concealer to help achieve a soft mini-wing."

2. Skipping Concealer At The Inner Corners

Eyeshadow can look its best, Jenny Stokes, beauty expert and founder/ CEO of MinimalJapan. says, when paired with strategic concealer to cover one's dark circles and under-eye areas.

“To look younger and fresher, apply concealer to dark areas around your eyes,” Stokes says. “Choose a shade or 2 lighter and apply to the inner corners of your eyes as these tend to darken first.”

The bottom line

The key to flattering mature eyes isn’t doing more—it’s doing things differently. Swapping harsh, heavy products for softer tones and being intentional with placement can make a noticeable impact. Think diffused liner instead of stark black, and targeted concealer to brighten where it counts. These subtle changes help enhance your natural features, leaving eyes looking bigger, fresher, and more awake.

Author:

Editorial Assistant

Mariam is an Editorial Assistant and writer at SheFinds, covering everything from style and beauty to health and wellness. Splitting her time between New York and Philadelphia, she brings a sharp eye for trends and a passion for storytelling to the digital space. With a strong editorial background, she’s always exploring the latest in fashion, skincare, and wellness. When she’s not writing or pitching, you’ll find her in the kitchen experimenting with new recipes or planning her next travel adventure. You can reach Mariam at mariam@shefinds.com.