Food

Costco Shoppers Give This New Bakery Item A ‘10/10’: ‘This Cake Screams Fall’

September 21, 2026 by Faith Geiger
shefinds | Food
Featured image

With the first day of fall on Tuesday, September 22, there’s never been a better time to finally embrace pumpkin spice season—but if you’re still holding onto the ghost of summer and need a little bit of motivation, biting into the new Pumpkin Bar Cake from Costco could do the trick.

That’s right: pumpkin spice goodies have been trickling into our favorite grocery stores since August, but one sweet treat just recently hit Costco shelves. Customers are already giving it a “10/10.” Get the deets on this new bakery treat below.

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Laura Jayne Lamb (@costcohotfinds)

Costco Pumpkin Bar Cake

Fall has officially arrived at Costco, and the new Pumpkin Bar Cake may be one of the bakery’s biggest seasonal temptations. The 2.5-pound cake features layers of pumpkin spice sponge cake, pumpkin mousse and cream cheese frosting. It’s currently priced at $16.99 at many Costco warehouses and is designed to yield around 20 slices.

An Instagram dedicated to keeping followers up-to-date on the warehouse’s latest and greatest, @costcohotdeals, recently spread the good news with a reel. “The cake is SO moist!! 10/10 this cake screams fall,” she wrote in the caption.

house unit img
Women Are Swapping Their Boring Water For This Ice Pop Electrolyte Mix!

Commenters were quick to share their excitement.

"I’m not gonna be able to say no to this," wrote one fan.

Another poked fun at the serving suggestion. "20 slices," they typed with a string of crying laughing emojis, "not with me around." Same.

For true pumpkin spice lovers, here's a challenge you might be up for, presented by another follower: "Goodness grief, could you imagine a Pumpkin spice latte with a slice of this." That would be a lot of sugar, but it would also be totally delicious—and a great way to enter fall.

What do you think? Are you excited to dig into pumpkin everything, or will you pass on this flavor?

Author:

Freelance Writer

Faith Geiger is a New York-based writer and editor. When she's not covering the latest in health and wellness for SheFinds, she spends her time watching reality TV with her roommates, browsing used bookstores, and enjoying live music. You can reach Faith at faith@shefinds.com.